What would you do with the eyes?

[BucksMike]

As it says I have tried a few things in Photoshop Elements but none successfully yet

[Geoff F]

Have you tried drawing a Selection around the problem area, feather slightly, then Desaturate; using the Hue/Saturation control. Possibly tweak the Lightness as well.

Cloning can work if you have a bit of correct colour to start with.

If all else fails, try drawing a Selection as before, then painting over the problem with a soft brush. A very dark brown often works. Preferable done on a new layer which you can adjust for Opacity (transpanency) if required.

[Hedge Witch]

I had a go at painting the eye in, but it's tricky as you can change the expression, this eye looks a bit like it belongs to a teddy bear

[Geoff F]

Yes that's the eyedea (sorry for the pun, just couldn't resist it).

Very good, and doing that on a new layer would give an option of varying the opacity slightly to make it look absolutely perfect.

And for anybody who doesn't have such a steady hand as you; creating a Selection means that you can't go wrong (possibly).

[cosmicma]

cheating might work

find a similar photo where the eyes are good and past into place with a new layer

blacken the original eyes so you can use transparency to
get them looking natural

just a thought...